AK-1.1: Difference between revisions

From Thesaurus Inscriptionum Raeticarum
Jump to navigationJump to search
No edit summary
 
(11 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{inscription
{{inscription
|reading=)nuale!?]ṇuale ri?ienalse!ri?ienalṣẹ
|reading=)nuale!?]ṇuale ri?ienalse!ri?ienalṣẹ
|reading_original={{c|E}}{{c|S}}{{c|L}}{{c|A|A19}}{{c|N}}{{c|E}}{{c|I}}?{{c|I}}{{c|R|R2}}{{c|E}}{{c|L}}{{c|A|A19}}{{c|U}}{{c|N}}[
|reading_original={{c|E}}{{c|S||d}}{{c|L}}{{c|A|A14}}{{c|N}}{{c|E}}{{c|I}}?{{c|I}}{{c|R|R2}}{{c|E}}{{c|L}}{{c|A|A14}}{{c|U}}{{c|N}}[
|direction=sinistroverse
|direction=sinistroverse
|letter_height_min=8 cm
|letter_height_min=7
|letter_height_max=11.5 cm
|letter_number_min=15
|letter_number_min=15
|word_number=0
|line_number=1
|line_number=1
|script=North Italic script
|script=North Italic script
|alphabet=Magrè alphabet
|language=Raetic
|language=Raetic
|meaning=unknown
|meaning=unknown
|object=AK-1 rock
|object=AK-1 rock
|position=left area
|position=bottom, left
|orientation=90
|orientation=90
|craftsmanship=engraved
|craftsmanship=engraved
|condition=damaged
|condition=damaged
|culture_archaeological=La Tène
|type_inscription=prob. votive
|sortdate=-250
|date=unknown
|date=5th–1st centuries BC
|sigla_tm=653493
|checklevel=2
|checklevel=0
|problem=Maße, meaning eintragen?
|disambiguation=AK-1
|disambiguation=AK-1
}}
}}
== Commentary ==
== Commentary ==
Not previously published. Autopsied by TIR in July 2014.
Not previously published. Examined by TIR in July 2014.


Image in {{bib|Mandl 2011}}: Abb. 138 (photo). Photo of the entire rock wall in {{bib|Mandl 2011}}: Abb. 136.
Image in {{bib|Mandl 2011}}: Abb. 138 (photo).


Length min. 52 cm. Running downwards in a slight curve on a small protrusion on the very left edge of the rock wall, the leftmost one of a group of three (Bildstelle 1, incl. [[index::AK-1.2]] and [[index::AK-1.3]]).
Length min. 52 cm; the last character at about 80 cm above the ground. Running downward in a slight curve on a small protrusion on the very left edge of the rock wall, the leftmost one of a group of three (Bildstelle 1, with [[index::AK-1.2]] and [[index::AK-1.3]]).


Traces of characters can be seen starting from the darker area of rock above the inscription, but no reading can be offered. The first usable group consists of the lower parts of two hastae, the second one possibly {{c||N}} with the angle all but gone. {{c||A19}}{{c||U}} are fairly well legible, {{c||E}}{{c||L}} are unambiguous. Next, {{c||R2}} with the curve made up of three scratches, followed by {{c||I}}, is unproblematic. Close to {{c||I}} a clearly visible hasta featuring a doubtful assortment of bars: A half-sized {{c||S}} appears to be attached to its upper end; this making no sense, {{c||E}} seems the most likely reading epigraphically, but see below. The next hasta, though slightly curved, is probably {{c||I}}, {{c||N}}{{c||E}} are unambiguous. Well legible {{c||L}}{{c||A19}} are the last letters which fit onto the face of the protrusion; the last two had to be engraved into the concave part below it and are accordingly hard to read. If the last letter is {{c||E}}, its two lower bars appear to be turned upward.
Traces of characters can be seen starting from the darker area of rock above the inscription, but no reading can be offered. The first usable group consists of the lower parts of two hastae, the second one possibly {{c||N}} with the angle all but gone. {{c||A14}}{{c||U}} are fairly well legible, {{c||E}}{{c||L}} are unambiguous. Next, {{c||R2}} with the curve made up of three scratches, followed by {{c||I}}, is unproblematic. Close to {{c||I}} a clearly visible hasta featuring a doubtful assortment of bars: a half-sized {{c||S|d}} appears to be attached to its upper end; this making no sense, {{c||E}} seems the most likely reading epigraphically, but is phonetically suboptimal. The next hasta, though slightly curved, is probably {{c||I}}, {{c||N}}{{c||E}} are unambiguous. Well legible {{c||L}}{{c||A14}} are the last letters which fit onto the face of the protrusion; the last two letters had to be engraved into the concave part below it and are accordingly hard to read. If the last letter is {{c||E}}, its two lower bars appear to be turned upward.


If the reading of the first visible part of the inscription is correct, we can isolate the suffix group {{m||-nu}}{{m||-(a)le|-ale}} and assume a patronymic in the pertinentive case, with the personal name base illegible. While it would be convenient to find the same group, amply attested in the rock inscriptions of [[index::Steinberg]] and also a few more times on [[index::AK-1 rock|this rock]], on the end of the inscription, we could not contrive, on the day of the autopsy, to read {{c||E}}{{c||L}}{{c||A19}}{{c||U5}}{{c||N}} instead of {{c||E}}{{c||S}}{{c||L}}{{c||A19}}{{c||N}} – and not for lack of trying. One would have to dismiss the quite distinct bar of {{c||A19}} as unintentional, assume that the trace of {{c||S}} represents the missing part of {{c||A19}}, and while the two errant bars of doubtful {{p||e}} might be ignored to get {{c||L}}, there is no trace of another letter {{c||E}} visible after it. For the sequence {{w||ri?ie}} in the middle, compare [[index::ST-2]], but note that although {{w||rieie}} is phonetically suboptimal, there is hardly space for the extension of a bar crossing the hasta (for either {{c||T}} or {{c||Z}}) between the hasta of the letter in question and preceding {{c||I}}.
If the reading of the first visible part of the inscription is correct, we can isolate the suffix group {{m||-nu}}{{m||-le|-ale}} and assume a patronym in the pertinentive case, with the base illegible. While it would be convenient to find the same group, amply attested in the rock inscriptions of [[index::Steinberg]] and also a few more times on [[index::AK-1 rock|this rock]], at the end of the inscription, we could not contrive, on the day of the examination, to read {{c||E}}{{c||L}}{{c||A14}}{{c||U5}}{{c||N}} instead of {{c||E}}{{c||S|d}}{{c||L}}{{c||A14}}{{c||N}} – and not for lack of trying. One would have to dismiss the quite distinct bar of {{c||A14}} as unintentional, assume that the trace of {{c||S|d}} represents the missing part of {{c||A14}}, and while the two errant bars of doubtful epsilon might be ignored to get {{c||L}}, there is no trace of another letter {{c||E}} visible after it. As concerns the sequence ''ri''?''ie'' in the middle, the ending would indicate an individual name.
{{bibliography}}
{{bibliography}}

Latest revision as of 19:33, 8 November 2021

edit with form
Inscription
Transliteration: ?]ṇualeri?ienalṣẹ
Original script: E sS dL sA14 sN sE sI s?I sR2 sE sL sA14 sU sN s[
Object: AK-1 rock (stone)
(Inscriptions: AK-1.1, AK-1.2, AK-1.3, AK-1.4, AK-1.5, AK-1.6, AK-1.7, AK-1.8, AK-1.9, AK-1.10, AK-1.11, AK-1.12, AK-1.13, AK-1.14, AK-1.15, AK-1.16, AK-1.17, AK-1.18, AK-1.19, AK-1.20, AK-1.21)
Position: bottom, left
Orientation: 90°
Script: North Italic script (Magrè alphabet)
Direction of writing: sinistroverse
Letter height: 77 cm <br /> – 11.5 cm
Number of letters: 15
Number of lines: 1
Craftsmanship: engraved
Current condition: damaged
Date of inscription: unknown
Date derived from:
Type: prob. votive
Language: Raetic
Meaning: unknown
Alternative sigla: TM 653493

Images

AK-1 rock - picture area 1
Object AK-1 rock - picture area 1 with inscriptions AK-1.1, AK-1.2 and AK-1.3.
AK-1.1
Inscription AK-1.1.
AK-1
Tracing of inscriptions on AK-1 rock.
AK-1 - picture area 1
Inscriptions AK-1.1, AK-1.2 and AK-1.3 - picture area 1.
AK-1.1
Inscription AK-1.1.

Commentary

Not previously published. Examined by TIR in July 2014.

Image in Mandl 2011: Abb. 138 (photo).

Length min. 52 cm; the last character at about 80 cm above the ground. Running downward in a slight curve on a small protrusion on the very left edge of the rock wall, the leftmost one of a group of three (Bildstelle 1, with AK-1.2 and AK-1.3).

Traces of characters can be seen starting from the darker area of rock above the inscription, but no reading can be offered. The first usable group consists of the lower parts of two hastae, the second one possibly N s with the angle all but gone. A14 sU s are fairly well legible, E sL s are unambiguous. Next, R2 s with the curve made up of three scratches, followed by I s, is unproblematic. Close to I s a clearly visible hasta featuring a doubtful assortment of bars: a half-sized S d appears to be attached to its upper end; this making no sense, E s seems the most likely reading epigraphically, but is phonetically suboptimal. The next hasta, though slightly curved, is probably I s, N sE s are unambiguous. Well legible L sA14 s are the last letters which fit onto the face of the protrusion; the last two letters had to be engraved into the concave part below it and are accordingly hard to read. If the last letter is E s, its two lower bars appear to be turned upward.

If the reading of the first visible part of the inscription is correct, we can isolate the suffix group -nu-ale and assume a patronym in the pertinentive case, with the base illegible. While it would be convenient to find the same group, amply attested in the rock inscriptions of Steinberg and also a few more times on this rock, at the end of the inscription, we could not contrive, on the day of the examination, to read E sL sA14 sU5 sN s instead of E sS dL sA14 sN s – and not for lack of trying. One would have to dismiss the quite distinct bar of A14 s as unintentional, assume that the trace of S d represents the missing part of A14 s, and while the two errant bars of doubtful epsilon might be ignored to get L s, there is no trace of another letter E s visible after it. As concerns the sequence ri?ie in the middle, the ending would indicate an individual name.

Bibliography

Mandl 2011 Franz Mandl, Felsbilder. Österreich – Bayern: Nördliche Kalkalpen [= Anisa – Verein für alpine Forschung 4], Haus im Ennstal: 2011.
Retrieved from "https://tir.univie.ac.at/index.php?title=AK-1.1&oldid=17794"