HU-7: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
Sindy Kluge (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| Line 14: | Line 14: | ||
|craftsmanship=embossed | |craftsmanship=embossed | ||
|condition=damaged | |condition=damaged | ||
|sigla_mlr=304 | |||
|checklevel=5 | |checklevel=5 | ||
|problem=nicht autopsiert; Abb bei Whatmough; wann soll eine sekundär angebrachte votivinschrift getilgt worden sein?; XXX-Inschrift; Länge, Interpretation | |problem=nicht autopsiert; Abb bei Whatmough; wann soll eine sekundär angebrachte votivinschrift getilgt worden sein?; XXX-Inschrift; Länge, Interpretation | ||
| Line 20: | Line 21: | ||
First published by <span style="font-variant:small-caps;">Whatmough</span> in {{bib|Hanfmann 1940}}: p. 32 f. | First published by <span style="font-variant:small-caps;">Whatmough</span> in {{bib|Hanfmann 1940}}: p. 32 f. | ||
Pictures in {{bib|Hanfmann 1940}} (photo and drawing = {{bib|Schürr 2003}}: fig. 2a), {{bib|Olzscha 1962}}: Taf. 4 (photo and drawing = {{bib|Schürr 2003}}: fig. 2b) and {{bib|Schürr 2003}}: pl. XXI (photo) and fig. 2c (drawings). | Pictures in {{bib|Hanfmann 1940}} (photo and drawing = {{bib|Schürr 2003}}: fig. 2a), {{bib|Olzscha 1962}}: Taf. 4 (photo and drawing = {{bib|Schürr 2003}}: fig. 2b) and {{bib|Schürr 2003}}: pl. XXI (photo) and fig. 2c (drawings), {{bib|MLR}} photo and drawing (= {{bib|Frey 1962}} photo and drawing). | ||
'''Length ???''', running along the rim, starting at 0.9 cm to the right of one of the handle fittings (see drawing in {{bib|Schürr 2003}}: fig. 1). Separated into two parts by a space of 1.5 cm. Hardly damaged by corrosion – the situla was restored in 1961 and 1968; it is not known whether the inscription has been worked on in the process. As first observed by {{bib|Lunz 1974}}: 318 f. (Anm. 961), the reading is impeded by a number of oblique strokes in the lower part of the inscription, disrupting most of the letters. As those strokes only occur on the part of the rim which bears the inscription, it is generally assumed that someone made an effort to efface or invalidate what was most probably a votive inscription. | '''Length ???''', running along the rim, starting at 0.9 cm to the right of one of the handle fittings (see drawing in {{bib|Schürr 2003}}: fig. 1). Separated into two parts by a space of 1.5 cm. Hardly damaged by corrosion – the situla was restored in 1961 and 1968; it is not known whether the inscription has been worked on in the process. As first observed by {{bib|Lunz 1974}}: 318 f. (Anm. 961), the reading is impeded by a number of oblique strokes in the lower part of the inscription, disrupting most of the letters. As those strokes only occur on the part of the rim which bears the inscription, it is generally assumed that someone made an effort to efface or invalidate what was most probably a votive inscription. | ||
The older readings of {{bib|Hanfmann 1940|Whatmough}} and {{bib|Olzscha 1962|Olzscha}}, both of whom worked only with photos, are largely negligible, as they fail to distinguish between original inscription and secondary strokes. {{bib|Schürr 2003|Schürr}} in doing so could segment the text correctly and assign the inscription to the Raetic corpus. | The older readings of {{bib|Hanfmann 1940|Whatmough}} and {{bib|Olzscha 1962|Olzscha}}, both of whom worked only with photos, are largely negligible, as they fail to distinguish between original inscription and secondary strokes. {{bib|Schürr 2003|Schürr}} in doing so could segment the text correctly and assign the inscription to the Raetic corpus. | ||
{{bibliography}} | {{bibliography}} | ||
Revision as of 15:32, 14 July 2015
| Inscription | |
|---|---|
| Transliteration: | ṭẹḳiesiuφikuφanin / meφlainile |
| Original script: |           
|
|
| |
| Object: | HU-7 situla (bronze) |
| Position: | rim |
| Script: | North Italic script (Magrè alphabet) |
| Direction of writing: | dextroverse |
| Number of letters: | 27 |
| Number of lines: | 1 |
| Craftsmanship: | embossed |
| Current condition: | damaged |
| Archaeological culture: | Hallstatt [from object] |
| Date of inscription: | third quarter of the 6th century BC [from object] |
| Date derived from: | typology [from object] |
|
| |
| Language: | Raetic |
| Meaning: | 'by Dekie X-ed ? ?' |
|
| |
| Alternative sigla: | MLR 304 |
Images
 Third part of inscription HU-7
|
 Mark on the rim of HU-7 situla
|
 Object HU-7 situla with inscription HU-7.
|
 Inscription HU-7.
|
 Inscription HU-7
|
 First part of inscription HU-7
|
 Second part of inscription HU-7
|
 Inscription HU-7.
|
Commentary
First published by Whatmough in Hanfmann 1940: p. 32 f.
Pictures in Hanfmann 1940 (photo and drawing = Schürr 2003: fig. 2a), Olzscha 1962: Taf. 4 (photo and drawing = Schürr 2003: fig. 2b) and Schürr 2003: pl. XXI (photo) and fig. 2c (drawings), MLR photo and drawing (= Frey 1962 photo and drawing).
Length ???, running along the rim, starting at 0.9 cm to the right of one of the handle fittings (see drawing in Schürr 2003: fig. 1). Separated into two parts by a space of 1.5 cm. Hardly damaged by corrosion – the situla was restored in 1961 and 1968; it is not known whether the inscription has been worked on in the process. As first observed by Lunz 1974: 318 f. (Anm. 961), the reading is impeded by a number of oblique strokes in the lower part of the inscription, disrupting most of the letters. As those strokes only occur on the part of the rim which bears the inscription, it is generally assumed that someone made an effort to efface or invalidate what was most probably a votive inscription.
The older readings of Whatmough and Olzscha, both of whom worked only with photos, are largely negligible, as they fail to distinguish between original inscription and secondary strokes. Schürr in doing so could segment the text correctly and assign the inscription to the Raetic corpus.
Bibliography
| Hanfmann 1940 | George Maxim Anossov Hanfmann, "The Etruscans and their art", Bulletin of the Museum of Art, Rhode Island School of Design 28 (1940), 1–35. |
|---|---|
| Lunz 1974 | Reimo Lunz, Studien zur End-Bronzezeit und älteren Eisenzeit im Südalpenraum, Firenze: Sansoni 1974. |
| Marchesini & Zaghetto 2019 | Simona Marchesini, Luca Zaghetto, "The Situla in Providence. A comprehensive analysis of inscription and decorative program", in: Simon Hye, Ulrike Töchterle (eds), UPIKU:TAUKE. Festschrift für Gerhard Tomedi zum 65. Geburtstag [= Universitätsforschungen zur prähistorischen Archäologie 339], Bonn: 2019, 329–341. |
